Published 23 December 2014
Animal rights campaigners filed a habeas corpus petition – a document more typically used to challenge the legality of a person’s detention or imprisonment – in November on behalf of Sandra, a 29-year-old Sumatran orangutan at the Buenos Aires zoo, arguing she was “suffering an unwarranted confinement”.
In a landmark ruling that could pave the way for more lawsuits, the Association of Officials and Lawyers for Animal Rights (AFADA) argued the ape had sufficient cognitive functions and should not be treated as an object.
The lawyers said that while Sandra was not identical to humans biologically, she was in fact like humans emotionally, and would be happier living in a semi-wild habitat.
“She has lived in captivity for 20 years and the point of today’s measure is for her to overcome having been held in captivity and depression, for her to be in semi-free conditions in a sanctuary,” AFADA lawyer Andres Gil Dominguez told local media.
“If humanity’s development centres on our broadening reasoning, then Sandra is subject to law.
“It’s a very basic recognition.”
The court agreed Sandra, born into captivity in Germany before being transferred to Argentina two decades ago, deserved the basic rights of a “non-human person”.
“This opens the way not only for other great apes, but also for other sentient beings which are unfairly and arbitrarily deprived of their liberty in zoos, circuses, water parks and scientific laboratories,” AFADA lawyer Paul Buompadre was quoted as saying in the daily La Nacion newspaper.
The AFADA is in the process of securing Sandra’s release to transfer her to a sanctuary where she is expected to live a more comfortable and happy life, lawyers said.
The Buenos Aires zoo has 10 working days to seek an appeal, and if they do not she could be moved to a semi-wild sanctuary in Brazil.
A spokesman for the zoo declined to comment.
The zoo’s head of biology, Adrian Sestelo, told La Nacion newspaper that orangutans were by nature calm, solitary animals which come together only to mate and care for their young.
“When you don’t know the biology of a species, to unjustifiably claim it suffers abuse, is stressed or depressed is to make one of man’s most common mistakes, which is to humanise animal behaviour,” he said.
Orangutan is a word from the Malay and Indonesian languages that means “forest man”.
Sandra’s case is not the first time activists have sought to use the habeas corpus writ to secure the release of wild animals from captivity.
A US court this month tossed out a similar bid for the freedom of Tommy the chimpanzee, privately owned in New York state, ruling the chimp was not a “person” entitled to the rights and protections afforded by habeas corpus.
In 2011, the animal rights group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) filed a lawsuit against marine park operator SeaWorld, alleging five wild-captured orca whales were treated like slaves.
A San Diego court dismissed that case.
AFP/Reuters » Full Story
A strong precedent set for non-human animals, recognising them as persons through the legal system. Plus great news for Sandra. May her remaining days be as close to what they should have been without such abhorrent human interference.
A horrific truck smash has ended in the agonising deaths of more than a hundred sheep, with several more running from the scene.
About 600 protesters demanding the closure of Australian slaughterhouses have shut down a major intersection in the CBD.
Dozens of animal liberation protesters have gathered at three Melbourne abattoirs in an attempt to block trucks carrying livestock in for 16 hours.
Want a free copy of the greatest love story every told? The first 30 people to become Animal Liberation Victoria monthly supporters will get a copy of the new Esther the Wonder Pig book. You will also be helping us save lives.
An exciting opportunity has arisen to join our team at Animal Liberation Victoria, as a casual Outreach and Volunteer Coordinator.
Is bringing dead calves to a dairy farmers’ rally a stunt in bad taste, or a clever way of highlighting some harsh realities of the industry?